Can Nutrition Impact The Training of Dogs and Cats?
by Dr. Karyn Kanowski
Antisocial behavior, aggression, or untrainability are among the common reasons that dogs and cats are surrendered to animal shelters every day. In many of those cases, better preparation, education, and dedication by owners may have prevented those pets from being abandoned, but could a change in diet have made a difference? In this article, we will explore the influence that different ingredients and nutrients can have on behavior, look at the new directions this research is heading, and how nutrition can affect the training of dogs and cats.
Nutrition and Survival
As evolution shows, the fittest individuals are the ones that survive and breed, so eating the right things has been an important strategy for survival and success. Animals in the wild will select foods that meet their nutritional needs and will even search for specific items to address or prevent deficiencies. How they are able to identify what they are lacking and how to correct it is still a mystery, but when provided with a wide selection of foods, they will generally consume the right balance of protein, carbohydrates, fats, vitamins, and minerals.
The problem domestic pets can face is when the food provided is not properly balanced and there are no alternatives for them to correct that problem. For instance, a dog fed a diet that is too high in carbohydrates will need to consume more of that food to also meet its protein needs and the excess is then stored as lipids, which can have an influence on health behavior.
It is well established that diet quality and nutrient balance have a significant impact on health and wellbeing, does this affect training? To answer that question, let’s start with some human examples.
Human Observations
There have been several experimental trials undertaken at prisons and detention centers on how behavior is affected by the use of vitamin and mineral supplements. The results have shown a convincing reduction in violence and antisocial behavior amongst inmates receiving supplements when compared with those eating a less balanced diet.
Similar studies have been conducted amongst juveniles with a high incidence of delinquency, yielding similar results. The conclusions being drawn are that consuming the appropriate balance of vitamins and minerals improves brain function and cognition, reducing antisocial behavior and violence.
The role of nutrition in canine behavior is a field that is growing in popularity and interest, but there is currently limited scientific evidence to draw definitive conclusions, even less so for cats. Recently, the effects of protein content on behavior have come under the microscope, but focusing on this alone may lead to further problems.
Proteins, Tryptophan and Behavior…Oh My!
Most canine nutritionists agree that protein levels in dog food have an effect on behavior, but there is a lack of consensus over the nature of that effect. The trouble with focusing on a single nutritional item is that it can lead to imbalances elsewhere, so is there a way to optimize the levels of one nutrient without negative impacts?
The answer may be in reducing overall protein content, and at the same time, adding specific amino acids (the building blocks of proteins) that have been proven to positively impact behavior and well-being. Encouraging results have shown that a diet of low to moderate protein combined with the addition of the amino acid Tryptophan can have a beneficial impact on dog behavior, reducing aggression and anxiety and improving attention span and trainability.
Tryptophan is a precursor to serotonin, a neurotransmitter that improves mood and cognitive function, so reducing levels of non-essential proteins and adding beneficial amino acids may strike the right balance.
What About Cats?
The jury is out on whether we train cats or they train us, but being obligate carnivores makes their dietary requirements more straightforward. Cats need higher protein and fat levels than dogs, and when fed a high-quality diet, require only a few additional nutrients to meet their metabolic needs.
Much of the research into feeding and behavior in cats tends to be focused on how they are fed, rather than what. Being a species with a significant prey drive, having food placed in a bowl twice a day will likely lead to frustration, depression, or acting out.
Hiding food in different locations or using food-dispensing toys can help your cat feel challenged and stimulated, and similar approaches can also help occupy your destructive dogs. A cat that feels stimulated and alert is far more likely to be interested in its surroundings and more responsive to training.
Conclusion
There is anecdotal consensus that nutrition plays an important role in dog and cat behavior and therefore, training. However, this area needs more research before snap decisions and assumptions can be made about what foods are “good or bad”.
Research supports the idea that feeding a high-quality diet that meets nutritional needs has a positive impact on behavior and cognition in humans, as well as a reduction in violence and aggression. It would be reasonable to believe this will apply to dogs and cats as well.
There have been encouraging results with the manipulation of proteins (rather than a simple reduction) on canine behavior which may prove invaluable in improving not only their health and wellbeing but our relationship with them too.
Pets that are alert, healthy, and mentally stimulated will invariably be more responsive to training and positive reinforcement than those whose nutritional needs are not being met, so before deciding that a pet “cannot be trained”, take a look at what they are being fed.
Other Sources
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5385817/
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12091259/
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10706231/
https://stud.epsilon.slu.se/9460/1/harju_c_160825.pdf
Sleepypod’s Clickit Sport in-vehicle safety harness for dogs is designed to be light and easy to use without sacrificing safety. Its unique Infinity Loop webbing design, in combination with a padded vest, work together to distribute and reduce damaging forces that can cause injury in an accident. The harness’ three points of contact reduce forward and lateral movement in the event of a collision or sudden stop. One of the safest dog safety harnesses in an auto collision, it earned the highest possible five-star safety rating from the Center for Pet Safety. It comes in four sizes—small (16.5-22 in.), medium (22.5-28 in.), large (28.5-34 in.), and extra-large: 34.5-40 in.—and four colors: Jet Black, Strawberry Red, Orange Dream, Robin Egg Blue. 
If your cat loves tuna, B.F.F. (Best Feline Friend) wet cat food is for you. The food’s main ingredient is red or dark meat tuna; it’s second is a high-quality meat, including chicken, duck, lamb, salmon, shrimp, bonito, tilapia and beef. All of the fish is wild-caught except for tilapia and all catches are certified safe for dolphins and turtles. It comes in 3.0- and 5.5-oz. cans (some varieties also come 10-oz. cans) in six distinct varieties in gravy or aspic, and 3.2.-oz. pouches, also in six distinct flavors in gravy. 
The PetLogix Zinger and Zinger Jr. dog-toy launchers offer a variety of interchangeable throw accessories, making playtime more fun and exciting for your dog and you. The Zinger is designed for medium and large dogs; the Jr. is for small dogs and puppies. Both Zingers feature a comfort handle and hands-free pick-up. In addition, the launchers’ top angle can easily be adjusted to match your throwing style and alter each throw’’s trajectory. Accessories include the Zing Bumby and Zing Cube in small, medium and large sizes, and the Zing Shot in small and medium/large. 
Two out of three cats agree: Catnip is awesome! If your feline is in the majority, check out Coastal Pet Products Turbo Compressed Catnip Toys. Featuring North American-grown compressed catnip and multiple textures, such as faux fur, these toys are designed to entice cats to play. Their long lasting catnip can provide your cat(s) with hours of entertainment, exercise and mental stimulation. They are available in bird (6.25 in.) and ball (1.5 in.) shapes. 
For cat owners with limited floor space (and no room for a cat tree), Square Cat Habitat’s Fremont Perch can provide an ideal retreat from indoor felines. Part of the company’s Bridge Series, the perch can be easily mounted on walls, under windowsills or any open wall. Measuring 25 1/8 in. wide by 12 in. deep and 3.4-in. thick, its unique design hides all the hardware and is able to support up to 50 pounds of cats. Featuring Velcro-backed removable inserts in two textures—faux mohair and plush—they come in three wood styles: Laminated Sustainable Design Fiberboard (SDF); Laminated FSC Birch Plywood and Architectural Bamboo Plywood. The mohair inserts come in 9 different colors, the plush in 10. 
STAYbowl™ NO-SLIP/NO-TIP is designed to be a tip-free dish for cats and dogs who are prone to spilling their food and/or water. The patent-pending bowl includes an elastomeric, silicone ring around the base that resists sliding on hardwood floors and other smooth surfaces. Its ergonomic design prevents pets from dumping their food and water, saving you time and money. Featuring a sleek, modern look, the dishwasher-safe bowl is available in four bright colors—sky blue, spring green, fuchsia and lilac—and comes in two sizes: 1/4 cup and 3/4 cup. 
Every dog and cat, whether naughty or nice, deserves a fun and festive holiday toy and West Paw Design has new ones for dogs and one for cats. The white-and-white striped Holiday Bear comes in two sizes (9 in. and 6 in.), contains a squeaker for extra fun. The soft and cuddly Holiday Stocking and Holiday Mitten are ideal for play or nap time; both are 6 inches in size. The bright-red Holiday Star is a soft, plush squeaker toy, 4 inches in size. In addition to the three new toys, the holiday line for dogs includes reindeer, gingerbread men, candy canes, Christmas trees and merry bones. For cats, West Paw Design offers the new Catnip Star. Hand-filled with USDA-certified organic catnip, your cat will love batting around and snuggling with the soft, Christmas-green toy. If you really want to spoil your cat, consider getting her a Holiday Field Mouse and/or a Holiday Big Sky Mouse as well. 
Zuke’s PureNZ Jerky Dog Treats are handcrafted in small batches from New Zealand sourced ingredients. Every pouch contains 80 to 90 percent real meat protein, such as grass-feed beef, green-lipped mussels, salmon and whitefish, along with high-quality fruits and vegetables. The limited-ingredient dog treats are available in four forms: 4-calorie Bites in Beef with Rabbit, Beef with Lamb and Beef with Venison recipes; soft, Cords in Beef & Turkey, Beef & Chicken and Beef & Duck recipes; thin-sliced Cuts in Beef with Salmon, Beef with Whitefish and Beef with Green Lipped Mussel recipes; and Steaks in Beef with Carrot, Beef with Potato and Beef with Sweet Potato recipes. Each form and recipe comes in 5-oz. resealable bags. 
Pamper your finicky felines this holiday season with Soft ‘n Tasty Baked Bites cat treats from Caru Pet Food. The first ingredient in these small-sized baked bits is USDA-inspected meat—chicken, chicken liver, salmon. Other beneficial ingredients include chickpeas, chicken broth and fish oil. The grain- and soy-free tidbits are formulated without any artificial colors, flavors or preservatives. Made in the USA by a family-owned company, the treats come in two recipes: Chicken and Salmon. 
Does your dog like to chew on toys? If yes, then KONG Dotz dog toys just might end up on your holiday shopping list. The interactive toys come in three shapes—circle, square and triangle—and feature layered textures (the dots) that will entice and delight the most eager of canine chewers. The toys’ playful, unpredictable bounce keeps dogs guessing as to where they’ll land next, while the nubby dots help keep dogs’ teeth and gums clean and healthy. To see the toys in action, click 
Keep your cats entertained—and away from the holiday decorations—with Coastal Pet Products’ Turbo Random Roller Cat Toy. Measuring 22-in. round, the interactive toy is designed to offer your cat (or cats) hours of mental stimulation and physical fun. The unpredictable movement of the battery-powered ball appeals to cats’ hunting instincts, while the dual-sided cover makes enticing crinkle noises during play—and keeps the ball from rolling away. Battery included. Click 
Petcurean Gather™ Organic pet food for dogs and cats is formulated using sustainably produced, certified organic ingredients that are caringly blended and balanced to provide your dog or cat with natural premium-quality nutrition. With nothing added that’s not needed, the pet foods feature single-source proteins, organic peas, lentils and other essential ingredients, such as omega 3 and 6 oils, to provide healthy, tasty meals for your dog or cat. There is one recipe for cats: Free Acres Organic Free-Run Chicken, which comes in 4- or8-lb bags. And three recipes for dogs, including Wild Ocean Line-Caught Cod and Free Acres Organic Free-Run Chicken, which are available in 6- or 16-lb. bags. 
Your feline companions deserve to look and feel their best while remaining safe indoors and out. Angel Pet Supplies’ Studded Cat Collars not only look great, their elastic breakaway and bell safety features ensure your cats stay safe wherever they are. The genuine leather cat collars are lightweight and comfortable, and come in two sizes—10 in. and 12 in.—and six stylish colors: black, white, pink, red, purple and turquoise blue. They are available from variety of independent pet retailers—brick-and-mortar and online. 
Could your dog do with a little extra protection from the weather this winter? Kruuse’s Buster brand offers a range of stylish jackets and coats for dogs that will help keep your best friend warm and dry in all types of weather. The Outdoor Winter Jacket provides warmth in extreme winter conditions; the Raincoat protects dogs in wet and windy weather; the Active Dog Jacket provides fashionable warmth; and the City Dog Jacket provides functional style on chilly days. All of the jackets and coats are easy to put on and take off; come in a range of colors; and are available in nine sizes, from XXS to XXL, for a comfortable and secure fit. 
OurPets® Pounce House™ is designed to stimulate cats’ hunter instinct and engage them in fun and healthful play. A motorized (and quiet) feather wand spins randomly to entice cats inside, while the large multiple openings provide them with easy access to bat at and pounce on their prey. After an exhausting workout, the ample-sized house (18x18x15 inches) is a great place for a catnap until it is time to spring back into action. The house is easy to set up and fold for storage; the wand’s motor is removable and powered by two AAA batteries (not included). 
Rosie’s™ Soft Dog Treats are made with thoughtfully sourced ingredients, including 100 percent vegetarian-fed chicken, sustainably sourced salmon, chia and flax seeds. The grain- and soy-free treats come in four dog-palate-tempting flavors in 6-oz. resealable bags: Peanut Butter with Banana, Salmon and Ginger, Pumpkin with Cinnamon, and Chicken and Rosemary. As an added bonus, when you buy a bag of Rosie’s treats, you will also be helping homeless dogs find their forever homes. Through its Rescue Ally Project, Rosie’s will donate 10 percent of its proceeds to four rescues twice a year and place their images and stories on the treats’ packaging. 
“The Dog Tales Collection” by Patricia A. Brill, PhD, is an award-winning set of illustrated books that help parents start a conversation with their children about caring for pets. Three of the books—“Do Bad Dogs Get Cancer?” “The Road to Recovery is Paved with Dog Treats!” and “Don’t Say Good Bye Just Say See You!”—help children understand what occurs when a pet or loved one has cancer, under goes surgery and/or stays overnight at a hospital or dies. The fourth book, “Porsche Bella’s Forever Home” shows children the benefits of rescuing, fostering and/or adopting animals. 
If your cat loves fish, consider adding Cat Sushi cat treats from SF Pet Foods to your shopping list. Made from just one ingredient—100 percent skipjack tuna—the all-natural, flaked treats are high in protein and low in fat, making them deliciously healthful for discerning felines everywhere. Using an ancient process that slowly dries the fish and then slices it into extremely thin pieces, Cat Sushi features only the largest flakes. It is great as an appetizer or a standalone treat and can be mixed in with dry or wet food. 
Ever wondered what your dog does at home while you’re away? The Petzi Treat Cam™ lets you check in on your pets and share treats with them from anywhere at any time. The app-controlled, Wi-Fi-connected remote pet treat dispenser makes it easy to check-in and interact with your pet from any smartphone or tablet. The cam features a wide-angle camera with night vision, high-quality audio and a universal treat launcher that works with any dry, crunchy treat smaller than 1 inch. It comes with multiple mounting options so that you can place the treat cam wherever it best suits your needs. A dedicated iOS or Android app controls the device and makes it easy to share captured images. 
Nekochan’s handcrafted and extremely realistic Neko Flies cat toys are designed to provide hours of exercise and fun for your cat—and you. Made with only cat-safe materials, the dangling toys come in eight critter shapes that are sure to captivate your cat: a creepy, crawly spider with dangly legs; an iridescent-winged dragonfly; a furry and a fluffy long-tailed mouse; a dangly legged centipede; a long-tailed cicada; an iridescent winged butterfly; and a BirBug (part-bird, part-bug). The toys attach to either a basic, 22-in. clear acrylic rod or an adjustable (18, 25 and 32 in.), telescoping rod made of graphite material. 
P.L.A.Y.’s Pet Teepee provides a fun and safe snuggle space for your pet, and adds an architectural design element to your home. Constructed of 100 percent, cotton canvas and pinewood poles, the cozy hideout features a circular front opening and removable interior cushion, making it great spot for your dog or cat to play or nap. Designed for easy set-up and care (the canvas is machine washable and dryer friendly), the durable Pet Teepee comes in four styles—Moroccan pattern in navy blue or marsala, denim and classic—measuring 24.8 x 24.8 x 29.1 inches in size. 
Get your dog packed up and ready to go on a long or short hike with Kurgo’s lightweight, tough, adjustable-fit Baxter Pack dog backpack. Designed to withstand rugged outdoor conditions, it has eight different adjustment points to get the proper fit for any dog. The backpack includes a rear-mounted leash hook that works like a harness and the ergonomic padded spine support contours to a dog’s back for a comfortable fit and provides weight distribution for the two saddlebags. The pack has space to store all of your canine’s travel essentials (food, treats, toys, first-aid supplies and travel bowls) and includes a large handle to help dogs over rock scrambles or extract them from water. Available in two sizes, the pack comes in Barn Red, Coastal Blue, Sea Glass, Purple & Gray, Black & Orange and Ink Blue & Electric Green. 
Handcrafted from real wood and designed to complement any room, the Curio® reimagines the cat litter box as a piece of fine furniture. Inspired by classic mid-20th century design, it is made in the USA of furniture-quality, pre-finished europlywood. Inside is a custom-fitted Curio Litter Liner litter pan, which is constructed from durable, waterproof polymer and features 10-in. high walls for litter retention and side handles for easy lift out. (The Curio also accommodates many standard size litter pans.) It is available in three styles: maple, walnut and patterned walnut and comes with a 30-day money-back return policy and is covered by a limited one-year warranty. 
AnimaTwists are a new kind of dog toy that lets you mix and match components to make ideal playthings—kibble ball, chew-filled toy, rope/treat toy or rope/treat/chew-filled toy—for your canine companion. The Classic Set includes a Chew Decker, a Rope Kibbler (which includes a bottom cap to create a kibble ball) and one AnimaChew. All of the components are also sold separately. The toys are made of nontoxic nylon and polyester-cotton dental rope. AnimaChews are made in the USA and contain just three ingredients: cow’s milk, salt and limejuice. 
Pet Botanics’ Simply Salmon Strips and Simply Salmon Cutlets dog treats are made from 99 percent fresh Atlantic salmon that is flash frozen and shipped to Florida, where it is smoked to retain taste, color and nutritional value (the remaining 1 percent is sea salt used in the smoking process). The treats have a tantalizing aroma and delectable taste that will entice even the finickiest canine. Naturally loaded with omega fatty acids, the treats are also free of antibiotics, hormones and artificial flavors and colors. 
The Hydro Pet is an automatic outdoor watering system designed to provide fresh water for your pets while recycling the old water to nearby plants, shrubs or trees in your yard. The system’s BPA-free, 1.05-gallon bowl incorporates three micro-jets that agitate the water to help expel light debris and insect larvae. Easy to install to existing outdoor faucets and drip or sprinkler systems, each kit contains everything you need for setup and includes three stakes to anchor the bowl in place. The Hydro Pet is ideal for any small to large pets—dogs, cats, rabbits, chickens, pigs, etc.—that spend time outdoors. 
Isle of Dogs’ new functional dog treats, Daily Essentials, are formulated to provide a daily dose of whole-food goodness with a delicious crunch. Made and sourced in the USA, the all-natural, pumpkin-based treats’ simple recipe includes only grains, fruits, vegetables and herbs. Dairy-, gluten- and soy-free, the dog treats come in 14.-oz. boxes and four delectable varieties: Healthy Skin & Shiny Coat with carrots, cranberry and rosemary; Puppy Growth & Brain Development with banana, peanut butter and broccoli; Cleans Teeth & Freshens Breath with apples, parsley and peppermint; and Hip, Joint & Bone Health with blackberries, raspberries and ginger. 
West Paw Design’s charismatic Caterpillar cat toy is designed to keep felines entertained for hours on end and afterwards snuggle up with it for a restful nap. Filled with premium, USDA certified organically grown catnip and a sewn-inside tinkling bell, your cat won’t be able to leave this floppy, wiggly toy alone. Handcrafted in Montana and made from soft sheepskin, it is available in two colors: Robin Blue or Wine Red. 
Your pets can now celebrate Oktoberfest with you anytime thanks to Fromm Family Foods latest entrée: Hasen Duckenpfeffer, a grain-free dry food for dogs and cats. Specially prepared in small batches, the recipes for Hasen Duckenpfeffer for Dogs and Hasen Duckenpfeffer for Cats were inspired by traditional German rabbit stew. They feature rabbit and duck together with potatoes, carrots and celery. The dog food is available in 4-, 12- and 26-lb. bags; the cat food comes in 2-, 5- and 15-lb. bags.
